This content has affiliate links, and we may earn a small commission from qualifying purchase if you buy through our recommended link.

Dave Portnoy Highest Pizza Review

**Dave Portnoy’s Highest Pizza Review: The Quest for the Perfect Slice**

There’s no denying that Dave Portnoy, the founder of Barstool Sports, has carved a niche for himself as the ultimate pizza connoisseur. With his famous “One Bite” pizza reviews, Portnoy has become an internet sensation, racking up millions of views and followers. But have you ever wondered which pizza has earned the coveted title of “Dave Portnoy’s highest pizza review”? In this article, we’ll dive into Portnoy’s pizza journey, explore what makes a pizza worthy of his approval, and unveil the highest-rated pizza according to the man himself.

**Dave Portnoy: The Pizza Renaissance Man**

Dave Portnoy’s love for pizza runs deep. He embarked on his quest for the perfect slice back in 2017, armed with his signature catchphrase, “One Bite, Everybody Knows the Rules.” Since then, he has reviewed hundreds of pizzas across the United States and beyond, earning him the title of the unofficial pizza king. Through his pizza reviews, Portnoy combines humor, authenticity, and a genuine passion for pizza, captivating audiences and inspiring pizza lovers everywhere.

**What Makes a Pizza Worthy of Dave Portnoy’s Approval?**

When it comes to Portnoy’s pizza reviews, several factors come into play. While taste is paramount, other aspects, such as crust texture, sauce-to-cheese ratio, and overall presentation, also contribute to his rating. Portnoy values authenticity, favoring traditional New York-style pizza but remaining open to all pizza varieties. Above all, he seeks out pizzas with a distinct and memorable flavor, ones that leave a lasting impression on the taste buds.

**The Highest-Rated Pizza: Lucali in Brooklyn, New York**

After countless pizza reviews, one establishment has emerged as the pinnacle of Portnoy’s pizza journey: Lucali in Brooklyn, New York. Lucali, a quaint pizzeria tucked away in Carroll Gardens, has gained renown for its minimalist approach and dedication to quality. Portnoy awarded Lucali’s pizza a near-perfect score of 9.4, making it the highest-rated pizza on his scale.

At Lucali, simplicity reigns supreme. The pizza is crafted using a Neapolitan-inspired recipe, featuring a thin, chewy crust, fresh mozzarella, San Marzano tomatoes, basil, and a drizzle of olive oil. Each pie is made to order, ensuring optimal freshness and flavor. The combination of high-quality ingredients, expert craftsmanship, and a cozy ambiance makes Lucali a must-visit spot for pizza enthusiasts and Portnoy fans alike.

**Other Noteworthy Pizzas in Dave Portnoy’s Book**

While Lucali takes the crown for the highest-rated pizza according to Portnoy, it’s important to note that taste is subjective. Portnoy has sampled numerous outstanding pizzas that have come close to earning top honors. Some notable mentions include:

1. Di Fara Pizza, Brooklyn, New York: Di Fara’s pizza, with its perfectly charred crust and judicious use of toppings, earned a commendable 9.1 score from Portnoy. It is often cited as one of the best pizzerias in New York City.

2. Pizzeria Regina, Boston, Massachusetts: Portnoy praised Pizzeria Regina’s thin, crispy crust, awarding it an impressive 8.9 rating. The iconic establishment has been serving up delicious pizzas since 1926.

3. Santarpio’s Pizza, Boston, Massachusetts: Santarpio’s garnered an 8.8 rating from Portnoy for its classic, no-frills pizza. The family-owned pizzeria has been a local favorite for over a century.

4. Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana, New Haven, Connecticut: Frank Pepe’s legendary white clam pizza caught Portnoy’s attention, earning an impressive 8.7 rating. The thin, coal-fired crust and generous toppings make it a beloved choice for pizza purists.

**Frequently Asked Questions**

What is the significance of Dave Portnoy’s pizza reviews?

Dave Portnoy’s pizza reviews have gained immense popularity, not only for their entertainment value but also for their influence. His reviews can make or break a pizzeria’s reputation, leading to increased business or a decline in customers. Many pizza establishments eagerly await his visits, hoping to earn a favorable score and a nod from the pizza king himself.

How does Dave Portnoy choose which pizzas to review?

Dave Portnoy’s pizza reviews are a blend of spontaneous visits and fan recommendations. He often discovers new pizzerias during his travels or while exploring different cities. Additionally, he welcomes suggestions from his followers, who provide an endless stream of recommendations via social media. Portnoy’s willingness to try various establishments keeps his pizza reviews fresh and diverse.

Has Dave Portnoy ever given a pizza a perfect score?

While many pizzas have come close, Dave Portnoy has not yet awarded a perfect score of 10. The elusive search for a flawless slice continues, and fans eagerly await the day when Portnoy finds the one pizza that surpasses all expectations.

Final Thoughts

Dave Portnoy’s pizza reviews have transformed the way we view and appreciate pizza. Through his infectious passion, humor, and honest critiques, he has brought attention to the craft of pizza-making and celebrated the diverse pizza offerings across the United States. Whether you agree with his ratings or not, there’s no denying the impact of his reviews on the pizza industry. So next time you take a bite of your favorite slice, remember to think about what Dave Portnoy would say.

Leave a Comment