Best Potbelly Sandwich: All About Potbelly Sandwich (Menu, Price and More)

Potbelly Sandwich Shop is known for its fresh, toasty sandwiches that are packed with flavor and made to order.

From their classic originals to their unique signature creations, there’s a sandwich for everyone at Potbelly.

But among their wide array of choices, which one reigns supreme? Which is the best Potbelly sandwich that you absolutely have to try?

Let’s dive into the world of Potbelly and discover the answer to this delicious question.

Best Potbelly Sandwich Menu Price

SandwichPrice (USD)
A Wreck$7.99
Turkey Original$7.49
Grilled Chicken and Cheddar$7.79
Roast Beef Original$7.79
Tuna Salad$7.49
Chicken Salad$7.49
Skinny Mushroom Melt$7.49
Mediterranean Chicken$7.99
Turkey Bacon Cheddar$7.79

Best Potbelly Sandwich2

The Anatomy of the Perfect Potbelly Sandwich

Potbelly has mastered the art of sandwich-making, and it all starts with the five integral parts that make up the perfect Potbelly sandwich:

  1. Freshly Baked Bread: Potbelly’s bread is baked fresh daily and forms the perfect base for all their sandwiches.
  2. Premium Meats: Potbelly uses high-quality meats, sliced daily in-house for maximum freshness.
  3. Cheese Selection: With an array of cheese options, there’s a choice for every palate.
  4. Fresh Produce: Potbelly sandwiches include fresh, crisp veggies for a refreshing crunch.
  5. Signature Spreads and Sauces: From the signature Potbelly mayo to the unique hot peppers, the sauces and spreads add the finishing touch.

Skinny Sandwich vs. Potbelly Sandwich: What’s the Difference?

There’s a notable difference between a skinny sandwich and a regular Potbelly sandwich. A skinny sandwich has less meat and cheese, which reduces the calorie content by a third. But don’t be fooled, these sandwiches still pack a flavor punch. Let’s break down these differences in a table:

AspectSkinny SandwichRegular Potbelly Sandwich
Calorie ContentLowerHigher
Meat and Cheese AmountLessMore
Bread TypeThin-cutRegular
FlavorsStill packed with flavorHearty and flavorful

Do Potbelly Heat Their Sandwiches?

Yes, Potbelly heats their sandwiches. In fact, the sandwiches are toasted to perfection, ensuring the bread is crispy and the cheese is perfectly melted. This adds another layer of deliciousness to the already tasty sandwich.

What Comes on the Italian Sandwich from Potbelly?

The Italian sandwich from Potbelly is a fan favorite and for good reason. It’s packed with a variety of Italian deli meats, cheese, and delicious add-ons. Here are the key components:

  • Salami
  • Mortadella
  • Capicola
  • Ham
  • Provolone Cheese
  • Fresh veggies: Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo
  • Italian Seasoning
  • Potbelly Vinaigrette
  • Hot Peppers (optional but highly recommended for a spicy kick)

Top Potbelly Sandwich Recommendations

There are several Potbelly sandwiches that stand out due to their unique flavor combinations and popularity among customers. Here are a few that you should definitely consider trying:

The Wreck

Known as the original Potbelly sandwich, The Wreck is a delicious combination of salami, roast beef, turkey, ham, and Swiss cheese. It’s a meat-lover’s dream and is one of the most popular options on the menu.

The Italian

As mentioned above, the Italian sandwich is another top choice. With a variety of Italian deli meats, provolone cheese, and the right toppings, it’s a sandwich that’s bursting with flavor.

The Mediterranean

For a healthier option, the Mediterranean sandwich is a great choice. It’s a vegetarian sandwich that includes hummus, feta cheese, cucumber, artichoke hearts, and more. It’s refreshing and packed with different textures

The Turkey Club

The Turkey Club is a classic sandwich that’s made even better at Potbelly. It features turkey breast, bacon, and cheddar cheese.

The addition of avocado adds a creamy texture that complements the other ingredients perfectly.

The Pizza Sandwich

For pizza lovers, the Pizza Sandwich is a must-try. It includes pepperoni, meatball, capicola, marinara sauce, provolone cheese, mushrooms, and your choice of toppings. It’s like having a pizza in sandwich form!

Nutritional Values of Top Sandwiches

The nutritional value of each sandwich can vary depending on the ingredients and your choice of toppings. Let’s look at the nutritional values of the recommended sandwiches:

The Wreck66047g53g30g
The Italian72032g56g42g
The Mediterranean57020g67g26g
The Turkey Club52032g46g23g
The Pizza Sandwich85037g62g48g

Comparison of Potbelly Sandwiches with Other Similar Brands

Potbelly sandwiches stand out from other similar brands due to their fresh ingredients, unique flavor combinations, and the ability to customize each sandwich to your liking. Here’s how they compare to other brands:

BrandSandwich QualityVarietyCustomizationPrice
Jimmy John’sHighMediumLow$$
Panera BreadHighMediumMedium$$$

Unique Features of Potbelly Sandwiches

Potbelly sandwiches are unique in several ways. Some of these include:

  • Freshly baked bread daily.
  • High-quality meats and cheeses.
  • Wide variety of sandwich options.
  • Ability to customize your own sandwich.
  • Unique hot pepper blend for an added kick.
  • Warm, toasted sandwiches for a delicious experience.

How to Order the Best Potbelly Sandwich: A Step-by-Step Guide

  1. Choose Your Sandwich: Start by choosing your sandwich from the menu. You can choose from the originals, signatures, or even build your own.
  2. Pick Your Bread: Potbelly offers multigrain or regular bread.
  3. Choose Your Size: Decide between the original or the big size.
  4. Add Toppings and Extras: Customize your sandwich with the toppings and extras. You can add lettuce, tomato, mayo, hot peppers, and more.
  5. Choose Your Side and Drink: Complete your meal with a side and a drink.
  6. Place Your Order: You can order in-store, through their website, or via their app.

Customization Options for Potbelly Sandwiches

Potbelly offers a variety of customization options, including:

  • Bread Type: Choose from multigrain or regular bread.
  • Size: Select from original or big.
  • Meats: Add extra meat or change the type of meat.
  • Cheese: Add extra cheese or choose a different type of cheese.
  • Toppings: Customize your sandwich with a variety of toppings.
  • Sauces and Spreads: Add extra sauces or spreads for more flavor.

Availability and Locations

Potbelly is widely available across the United States, with over 400 locations. You can find a Pot

belly in major cities and towns, providing the same great quality sandwiches wherever you go.

Seasonal or Limited Edition Potbelly Sandwiches

Potbelly often has seasonal or limited edition sandwiches that offer a unique twist on their regular offerings.

Past examples have included the Turkey Fresco sandwich for summer and the Smoky BBQ Pulled Pork sandwich for BBQ season. Keep an eye on their menu to catch these limited-time offerings!

Frequently Asked Questions

How many calories are in a Potbelly sandwich?

The calorie content of a Potbelly sandwich can vary greatly depending on the type of sandwich and customization options. On average, a sandwich can range from 250 to over 1000 calories.

Does Potbelly have a vegetarian option?

Yes, Potbelly offers several vegetarian options, including the Mediterranean sandwich and the Vegetarian sandwich. You can also customize any sandwich to make it vegetarian.

What are the most popular sandwiches at Potbelly?

The most popular sandwiches at Potbelly include The Wreck, The Italian, and the Turkey Club.

Can you order Potbelly online?

Yes, you can order Potbelly online through their website or their app. They also offer delivery through various third-party apps.

Does Potbelly offer catering services?

Yes, Potbelly offers catering services. You can order sandwich bundles, salads, soups, and more for your events.

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, there is no definitive answer to the “best Potbelly sandwich” as it depends on individual tastes and preferences.

However, with this guide, you should be able to make an informed decision and find your own favorite sandwich at Potbelly.

Remember, the joy of Potbelly lies in the variety and customization, so don’t hesitate to experiment and try different combinations! Happy eating!

For more information, visit the official Potbelly website.

Leave a Comment