brickschicago.com is a participant in the Amazon affiliate program, we may earn a small commission from the qualifying sale of our suggested links. Learn more.

Top 10 Best Pizza Stone For Big Green EGG in 2022 – Flat Versatile Cookware Piece

Are you trying to find the best pizza stone for a big green egg? Well, join the club.

It seems as though this is a common problem point for everyone, and thousands of people from all over the world are searching for this same question.

In an attempt to remedy this, we have gone ahead and curated a list of some of the best pizzas stones in the market, and we have no doubt that at least one of the options we feature on this list is going to be to your liking.

Without further ado; let’s jump straight into it and take a look at some of the best pizzas stones for big green eggs in 2022.

Our Recommended Pizza Stone For Big Green Egg

BrandPrice
Kamado Joe
Cast Elegance
BBQgaskets
Cast Elegance
BBQ Future
Pizzacraft
Dracarys
American Metalcraft
Premium Products LLC
BBQgaskets.com

What is The Best Pizza Stone For Big Green Egg?

As you have likely already noticed, finding the best pizza stone for big green eggs is no simple task.

No, with the number of options out there, picking the best is a near-impossible feat, and this makes this whole ordeal much harder.

Moreover, when you factor in how tedious it can be to keep going through sub-par pizza stone, this fact just becomes all the more aggravating, and it is not uncommon for people to just stop using their big green eggs altogether.

Whilst there is no “best” pizza stop overall, there is one option that we think is going to be right for the vast majority of people, and this would be the Kamado Joe KJ-PS23.

Why is Kamado Joe Worth For Pizza Stone For Big Green Egg?

Kamado Joe has been at the top of the food appliances game for years now, and the number of high-quality products they have on offer is truly mind-blowing.

If you ever decide to get any product from this company, you can rest assured knowing that you are getting your hands on the best the market has to offer, and the chances of you having a good experience with them is extremely high.

You can never go wrong with Kamado Joe, and they are a great place to go for a wide array of cooking appliances.

10 Best Pizza Stone For Big Green Egg Reviews

As we mentioned before, there is not one pizza stone out there that is going to be perfect for everyone.

Different pizza stones have different positives and negatives, and different people are going to be better suited to different options.

This is exactly why we decided to go ahead and give you an extra nine options – you are near-assured to love at least one of the options we feature.

As long as you go through this list with your own wants and preferences in mind, you can’t go wrong, and we have no doubt that you are going to come out at the end of this article with a pizza stone that is a perfect fit for you.

01. Kamado Joe – Best Big Green Egg Pizza Stone

 

 

Highlighted Features

  • Made from ceramic
  • 9″D x 14.9″W x 0.6″H
  • Cooks 15” pizzas
  • Designed to create crispy crusts

The Kamado Joe KJ-PS23 undoubtedly takes our number one spot for the best pizza stone for big green egg.

This is simply down to the fact that this pizza stone excels in all areas across the board.

Wheater it’s durability, longevity, even heat distribution, or just overall quality, the Kamado Joe KJ-PS23 does it all, and it is immediately evident to anyone who gets to spend any time with this stone that it is the best on the market.

That’s not to say that it is fault-free. We found that the Kamado Joe KJ-PS23 is actually slightly smaller than it is advertised, and while this may not be a big deal, it’s definitely going to be worth looking into for some.

Pros

  • Distributes heat evenly
  • High-quality
  • Has a long lifespan

Cons

  • Slightly smaller than advertised

02. Cast Elegance – Best Big green Egg Pizza Baking Stone

 

 

Highlighted Features

  • Made from cordierite
  • 5/8th inches thick
  • Includes recipe E-book & scrapper
  • Has 16” of space

The Cast Elegance is a fantastic option for a big green egg pizza stone and were it not for one detrimental downside, we could have easily seen it giving the Kamado Joe KJ-PS23 a run for its money.

This entry is almost the perfect pizza stone, it’s large, has a good thickness, and even comes with a free E-book and scrapper.

Although, this is also where the problem lies. Many people have reported that the scrapper sheds small increments of its material immediately upon use, and this can actually make the stone unusable.

As long as you throw away the scrapper with this stone, you can’t go wrong, and there are very few other options on the market that are as high-quality as the Kamado Joe KJ-PS23.

Pros

  • Comes with a free recipe book
  • Easy to clean
  • Durable performance

Cons

  • Low-quality scrapper can ruin stone if used

03. BBQgaskets PS-14 – Best Pizza Stone Big Green Egg

 

 

Highlighted Features

  • Constructed out of stone
  • 9/16″ thick
  • High-temperature resistance
  • Can handle a lot of weight

The BBQgaskets PS-14 serves somewhat of a niche role, with it being 9/16” thick and heavy-duty.

This pizza stone is not going to be suited for everyone, and in reality, it would probably not be a good option for the vast majority of people because of its thickness.

However, if you have specific needs that demand a pizza stone that is incredibly thick and near-unbreakable, then the BBQgaskets PS-14 would be a perfect fit. It is a little small, with it only coming in at 14”.

Yet again, this just makes this pizza stone even more of a niche pick – for those of you that want to cook small, heavy, and dense foods, this stone is one of the few options on the market that will allow you to do so.

Pros

  • Super thick
  • Provide Incredibly strong temperture
  • Heavy-duty

Cons

  • Small (14 inches)

04. Cast Elegance PD-25121

 

 

Highlighted Features

  • Constructed with cordierite
  • Includes recipe E-book & scrapper
  • 5/8th inches thick
  • Has 16” of open space

Cast Elegance’s PD-25121 is an incredibly unique big green egg pizza baking stone, and it comes with a ton of perks that are not seen with other options on the market.

To give just a few examples of this; it is made out of cordierite, it comes with a free recipe E-book and scrapper, and it has 16” of open space.

This gives the Cast Elegance PD-25121 a ton of advantages over other options, and for some, it is going to be an excellent pizza stone. The only area where this stone falters is with its accessories.

The scrapper that is provided can actually damage the stone and make it unusable, and not only does this negate the free accessories entirely, but it could end up ruining the entire product as a whole.

Pros

  • Can cook large/heavy foods
  • Very spacious
  • Comes with free accessories & a recipe book

Cons

  • Low-quality scrapper can ruin stone if used

05. BBQ Future

 

 

Highlighted Features

  • Has 18” of open space
  • Made out of ceramic
  • Oval-shaped
  • Compatible with 18″ Kamado Grill and Chargriller 18″

The BBQ Future r is a great green egg pizza stone that has quite a lot to offer. This pizza stone is the largest stone on our list, with it measuring a staggering 18”.

This is going to be more than enough for even speciality dishes, and the number of opportunities that will become available to you with this stone is astonishing.

A nice extra feature for this entry is that it can also be flipped upside to allow you to bring the food closer to the oven and vice versa, making it incredibly versatile and opening even more options up to you.

The BBQ Future is fragile, so this is going to be something you need to look out for.

Although with proper care and caution, this pizza stone can be an incredible choice, and it manages to tick a ton of boxes.

Pros

  • Very large
  • Passed SGS testing
  • Can be used upside down for different effects

Cons

  • Fragile

06. Pizzacraft PC9898

 

 

Highlighted Features

  • 5″ wide
  • All-natural
  • FDA-safe
  • Made out of cordierite

There are quite a few features that set Pizzacraft’s PC9898 apart from the rest. First and foremost; this pizza stone is absolutely gigantic.

Coming in at a whopping 16.5”, you aren’t going to get a pizza stone much bigger than this, and this is going to be more than enough for the vast majority of people.

On top of this, it’s also all-natural – making it a perfect fit for those that make an effort to be environmentally friendly.

Although, as a side effect of its construction out of cordierite, many people that purchase this pizza stone come to find it emits an unpleasant smell.

While this doesn’t affect the food at all, it can certainly be a little off-putting, and it is something you are going to want to consider if you are thinking about getting this pizza stone.

Pros

  • Quite large
  • Rigorously tested
  • Doesn’t contain any unnatural materials

Cons

  • Can give off an unpleasant smell

07. Dracarys W-15

 

 

Highlighted Features

  • 15” wide
  • Made out of stone
  • designed to withstand up to 1500 degrees
  • Passed US FDA and European Union safety standards

Looking for a pizza stone that is large, durable, and able to withstand high temperatures? Well, the Dracarys W-15 might just be your best bet.

This pizza stone performs consistently well right across the board, and its only negative is somewhat negligible.

Speaking of its negative; the only real negative we could find for this one is that it does not come with instructions.

This can be easily remedied with a quick google search, and for what it is, we believe the Dracarys W-15 is well worth just watching a quick YouTube video for, and it is easily one of the top options on the market.

Pros

  • Can withstand high-temperatures
  • Heavy-duty
  • Can last for multiple years

Cons

  • Doesn’t come with instructions

08. American Metalcraft Economy 15

 

 

Highlighted Features

  • Made of ceramic stone material
  • 25 inches thick
  • Offers even heat distribution
  • Measures 15-inch in size

American Metalcraft’s Economy 15 is a great pizza stone, and for some people, this one is going to be a perfect fit.

Perhaps the most notable feature of the American Metalcraft Economy 15 is its modern design and structure – this stone doesn’t just look like a pizza stone from the twenty-first century; it functions like one too.

This stone has numerous features that make it a powerhouse at cooking pizzas – it’s thin so cooking times are drastically reduced, it’s 15” in size meaning it is large enough to cook almost any food imaginable, and it’s also made out of ceramic stone so the chances of it breaking are slim to none.

The only factor that holds the American Metalcraft Economy 15 is its unreliable build control.

When you buy this pizza stone, you can never ensure that you are going to get the same one as we reviewed, and there is a myriad of people out there that report their pizza stone broke from just one to three uses.

Pros

  • Looks great
  • Dimensions are incredibly precise
  • Long-lasting

Cons

  • Unreliable quality control

09. Premium Products LLC

 

 

Highlighted Features

  • 14 inches’ wide
  • Constructed out of stone
  • Versatile
  • Can be cleaned with just warm water

The Premium Products LLC is sturdy, easy to maintain, and is known for consistently giving every pizza in comes into contact with a crispy crust.

Taking its many positives into consideration; you may be wondering why this option is featured so low down on this list? Well, that would due to one large negative that we will talk about later on.

Back onto the positives; the Premium Products LLC is widely regarded as being one of the best pizza stones out there when it comes to replicating that delicious crust time and time again, and there are very few other options on this list that are able to boast this same characteristic.

As a nice bonus, this stone can also be cleaned with just soapy water – something which makes maintenance an absolute breeze.

However, as we said earlier, there is one big downside to the Premium Products B07PMLL99P, and that is its pungent smell.

Many people cite this stone as emitting a chemical-like odour, and as you would expect, this can make using it incredibly unappealing.

If this is going to be an issue for you, then it goes without saying that you may want to stay clear of the LLC.

Although, if you are able to put up with this glaring obvious negative, then you are going to be more than rewarded, and you will be able to get your hands on one of the best pizza stones on the market.

Pros

  • Easy to maintain
  • Gives a crispy crust every time
  • Very sturdy

Cons

  • Produces a chemical-like odour

10. BBQgaskets PS-15

 

 

Highlighted Features

  • Earthenware stone
  • Measures 15”
  • Has a high-temperature tolerance
  • Made for an XL oven

Whilst the BBQgaskets PS-15 does find itself at the bottom of our list, that’s not to say it isn’t worth a consideration.

The PS-15 actually has quite a few qualities that are going to make it well-suited to a sizeable portion of people, and if you just want a pizza stone that has an extraordinarily high-temperature tolerance and superb durability, then this may just be the option for you.

That’s right; the BBQgaskets PS-15 is actually one of the most resilient options on this list.

The one and only reason this pizza stone didn’t place any higher is because of its deceiving marketing.

This pizza stone is marketed as being fit for an XL green egg, but this is just not the case.

However, if you happen to just have a normal-sized big green egg and looking for an excellent option, the BBQgaskets PS-15 would be a prime choice, and you should not let its low position on this list put you off.

Pros

  • Durable
  • Large
  • Unlikely to break

Cons

  • Too small for an XL oven

Buying Considerations of The Best Big Green Egg Pizza Stone

Contrarily to popular belief, there is actually more than meets the eye when it comes to buying a pizza stone for big green eggs.

Purchasing any old pizza stone is just not going to cut it – there are a variety of factors you need to take into consideration, and neglecting to take heed to this advice is going to be detrimental to your entire big green egg experience.

This is exactly why paying close attention to this next section is going to be absolutely vital, and if you do, you may just find that your journey to find the best pizza stone becomes a whole lot easier.

01. Material

The material of a pizza stone matters for a variety of reasons. However, perhaps the most notable would be that it can have an effect on the taste and texture of your food.

Different materials can make food taste differently, and learning which material works best for you is only going to be achieved after doing a little research.

Do not just go ahead and get the first pizza stone you see – even if it is perfect in every way imaginable, there is no surety that you will like the taste that is produced, and this is exactly why it is important to read reviews of any pizza stone you are thinking about getting.

02. Thickness

Thickness is a factor that can have a substantial impact on how well your food is cooked.

Different thicknesses have different properties, and finding a thickness that works for you is the only way you can get the perfect pizza stone.

Unfortunately, just like with material, this is also going to take a little research to figure out.

Different thicknesses are going to be better suited to different people, and scouring the web to find out what thickness suits you best is going to be your best bet of getting a pizza stone that is right for you.

03. Durability

Durability is relatively self-evident. Nobody wants to get a pizza stone that is only going to last a matter of weeks, and unless you pay attention to the individual quality of every pizza stone you look at, this could undoubtedly end up happening to you.

As long as you go for a pizza stone that is made by a reputable brand and has a ton of positive reviews, you can’t go wrong, and this is one of the best ways you can ensure you get your hands on a pizza stone that is going to stand the test of time.

04. Size

The size of a pizza stone dictates what types of food you can cook. To give an example; you are not going to be able to cook an 18″ pizza on a pizza stone that is only 14″.

Taking this into consideration; going for a larger pizza stone is going to allow you to get access to the most cooking opportunities.

Although, it is worth noting that certain models of big greens eggs can only support specific sizes of pizza stone.

It is integral that you get a pizza stone that is compatible with your big green egg, and if not, you could end up just wasting your money.

05. Heat Resistance

Heat resistance is of the utmost importance when looking to buy a pizza stone.

This is even more so the case if you plan on cooking speciality foods that require an extremely high temperature – if this is the case, you are better off going for an option that was specifically designed to withstand extremely high temperatures.

Luckily, the vast majority of pizza stones will be able to handle a high enough temperature to cook most average foods, and if this is all you plan on doing, then worrying about heat resistance isn’t really something you need to do.

The Basic FAQs of Best Pizza Stone For Big Green Egg

01. What is a Pizza Stone?

A pizza stone is a utensil that is placed inside of a big green egg in order to ensure any food that is cooked is heated evenly and doesn’t get burned.

Without a pizza stone, the chances of your food getting burnt to a crisp are extremely high, and it goes without saying that you probably do not want to eat a pizza/any other food that is charred and burnt.

Pizza stones solve this issue entirely, and without them, big green eggs would be outright useless.

02. How Long Do Pizzas Stones Last?

The length of time that a pizza stone will last depends entirely on what pizza stone you choose to buy. Some pizza stones can last for years, while others may not be so kind.

As a general rule of thumb, the higher the quality of the pizza stone, the longer it is going to last, and you will not need to worry about it breaking anytime soon if it is high-quality and durable.

03. What Should I Look For When Getting a Pizza Stone?

There is a variety of factors you need to take into consideration when buying a pizza stone; the material, thickness, durability – the list goes on.

This is why doing some research is so incredibly important; if you don’t know what you are looking for, the chances that you are going to be able to pick out a good pizza stone are slim to none.

You should always make sure you go for a pizza stone that is high-quality and is able to withstand all the demands you need, and if you do this, you are unlikely to face any problems.

04. Do I Need a Pizza Stone When Using a Big Green Egg?

Yes. You need a pizza stone or some kind of equivalent when using a big green egg; without it, the food you cook would become outright uneatable.

You should never try and cook something with a big green egg If you do not have a pizza stone or some viable alternative, and if you choose to try your luck, you could be putting yourself in a potentially dangerous situation.

05. What Types of Food Can You Cook on a Pizza Stone?

When it comes to the question of what types of foods you can cook on a pizza stone, the number of potential answers we could give you is endless.

In reality, you could cook almost any food imaginable with a big green egg and a pizza stone, and the only real limit is your imagination.

Although, when it comes to the most common foods that people choose to cook on a pizza stone, the most notable candidates would be pizzas, bread, and other types of foods of a similar category.

Conclusion

We hope we have been able to give you a much better idea as to how you can find the best pizza stone for big green egg for you.

Most people often underestimate just how difficult a decision akin to this can be, and unless you want to endlessly replace every pizza stone you get, you may just want to take a little time to make sure you go for a high-quality option.

As long as you follow all of the information we have given you in this article, we have no doubt that you are going to become an expert in an all-things pizza stone, and the chances of you being able to pick out the best option for you will be exponentially increased.

Leave a Comment